Uninsured Motorist Arbitration in California: What Happens and How Long It Takes
When you and your own insurer cannot agree on an uninsured or underinsured motorist claim, California law sends the disagreement to arbitration, not to a jury. One neutral arbitrator hears the evidence and decides whether the other driver is legally responsible and how much your damages are. It is less formal than a trial, but it has real rules and deadlines. How long it takes varies a great deal, and no one can promise a date.
For the coverage itself, see our main guide to uninsured and underinsured motorist claims in California.
Why UM claims go to arbitration
Insurance Code section 11580.2(f) requires every uninsured motorist policy to say that two questions, whether you are legally entitled to recover damages and, if so, how much, will be decided by agreement between you and your insurer or, if you disagree, by arbitration. The arbitration is conducted by a single neutral arbitrator.
You can still sue the uninsured driver, but an award (or a court judgment confirming one) is not conclusive in that separate case (section 11580.2(f)).
Arbitration has to be started on time and by certified mail. Our guide on how to file an uninsured motorist claim explains the two-year rule.
What the arbitrator decides
The arbitrator decides fault (whether the uninsured or underinsured driver is legally responsible) and the value of your damages, such as medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. What your insurer then pays depends on your policy limit and any credits that apply, as our guide to how much an underinsured motorist claim can pay shows.
If you have, or may have, a workers’ compensation claim from the same crash, section 11580.2(f) says the arbitrator cannot go ahead until your condition is “stationary and ratable” (stable enough to be rated). If you claim a permanent disability in that workers’ compensation case, it generally must be decided or settled first unless there is good cause.
How the arbitrator is chosen
The statute requires one neutral arbitrator but does not say how that person is picked. The general arbitration law fills the gap. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.6:
- If the policy sets out a method, it is followed.
- If not, you and your insurer can agree on a method or simply on a person, for example a retired judge or an attorney who serves as a neutral.
- If there is no agreed method, or it fails, either side can ask the court. The court nominates five people, the two sides have five days to jointly choose anyone, and if they do not, the court appoints one of the nominees.
Within 10 calendar days of notice of the proposed appointment, the arbitrator must disclose in writing anything that could make a person reasonably doubt their impartiality, including other arbitrations in the past five years involving the same insurer or lawyer (Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.9). Either side can then disqualify the arbitrator by serving notice within 15 calendar days (section 1281.91).
Who pays? Unless the policy or an agreement says otherwise, each side pays its share of the arbitrator’s fees and expenses, plus its own lawyer and witness costs (Code of Civil Procedure section 1284.2).
Discovery: how each side gets information
Discovery is the formal exchange of information before the hearing. Section 11580.2(f) makes California’s Civil Discovery Act available to you and your insurer at any time after the accident. That can include:
- Written questions (interrogatories) and requests for admission, which either side may serve on the other without court permission once 20 days have passed since the accident (section 11580.2(f)(6)).
- Depositions: sworn questioning recorded by a court reporter. Your insurer may take yours.
- Requests for documents, and subpoenas for records from doctors, hospitals and employers.
- A medical examination the insurer arranges, on the timelines in section 11580.2(o).
Disagreements about discovery go to the superior court in a county where you could properly sue the uninsured driver, or a county your policy names (section 11580.2(f)(1)).
The hearing
Unless the policy or the two sides agree otherwise, Code of Civil Procedure section 1282.2 sets the basic rules:
- The arbitrator sets the time and place and serves notice at least seven days before the hearing.
- Each side may be heard, present evidence, and cross-examine witnesses. The formal rules of evidence do not have to be followed, and on request witnesses testify under oath.
- The arbitrator can adjourn or, for good cause, postpone the hearing.
There is no jury, and the hearing is usually held in an office or conference room rather than a courtroom. You may testify about the crash and how the injuries changed your life, and either side may call witnesses, including doctors. You have the right to be represented by an attorney (Code of Civil Procedure section 1282.4).
The award, and what comes after
The award must be in writing, signed, and decide every question submitted (Code of Civil Procedure section 1283.4). It must be made within the time the agreement sets or a court orders, and the two sides can extend that time (section 1283.8). After the award:
- Either side may ask a court to confirm, correct or vacate it (section 1285). If the award is confirmed, it is entered as a judgment and can be enforced like one (section 1287.4).
- A court can vacate an award only on the narrow grounds listed in section 1286.2, such as fraud, corruption, arbitrator misconduct that substantially hurt a party, or an arbitrator going beyond their powers.
- A request to vacate or correct must be served and filed within 100 days after service of a signed copy of the award; a request to confirm, within four years (section 1288).
How long it takes
No law sets a typical length, but it does set outer limits. Arbitration generally must be concluded within five years after it is started, or later in some workers’ compensation cases (section 11580.2(i)(2)), and the two sides can agree in writing to extend that time (section 11580.2(i)(4)).
What usually drives the timing:
- Whether you are still being treated, since it is hard to value an injury before doctors know how it will turn out.
- A workers’ compensation claim, which can hold up the arbitration.
- Records, depositions, and the medical examination.
- The arbitrator’s calendar.
- In an underinsured claim, collecting the at-fault driver’s limits first.
As a general guide only, these arbitrations often take many months from the demand to a hearing, and a year or more is not unusual. A claim can also settle at any point by agreement, including shortly before the hearing. No one can promise a timeline or a result.
Related guides
- Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims in California
- How much can I get from an underinsured motorist claim in California?
- How to file an uninsured motorist claim in California, step by step
About NMF Law Group
Attorney Joshua B. Adelpour spent nearly a decade helping insurance companies before founding NMF Law Group in 2022. Now he works only for people who got hurt, and the firm takes cases anywhere in California. Consultations are free. No fee or costs unless we win.
(213) 800-0706 | Info@NMFLawGroup.com
21051 Warner Center Lane, Suite 210, Woodland Hills, CA 91367
Our staff speaks Spanish.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to arbitrate my uninsured motorist claim in California?
If you and your insurer cannot agree on fault or the amount, yes. Insurance Code section 11580.2(f) requires those questions to be decided by agreement or, failing that, by arbitration before a single neutral arbitrator.
Who picks the arbitrator?
The policy’s method, if it has one. Otherwise you and your insurer can agree on a method or a person. If that fails, a court nominates five people and appoints one if the two sides cannot agree (Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.6).
How long does uninsured motorist arbitration take?
It varies a great deal with treatment, any workers’ compensation claim, discovery and the arbitrator’s calendar. Many months or more is common. By law, arbitration generally must be concluded within five years after it is started unless the two sides agree in writing to extend it.
Can I appeal an uninsured motorist arbitration award?
Only in narrow situations. A court can vacate an award on the grounds in Code of Civil Procedure section 1286.2, such as fraud, corruption, arbitrator misconduct, or an arbitrator going beyond their powers. A request to vacate must be served and filed within 100 days after a signed copy of the award is served.
Facing arbitration with your own insurer?
Tell us where your claim stands. We will explain the next steps and the deadlines that apply.
Get My Free Case ReviewOr call (213) 800-0706. Free consultation. No fee or costs unless we win. We respond to every message the same business day.
This page is general information about California law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship. Arbitration rules can turn on the wording of your own policy and every case turns on its own facts. For advice about your situation, call (213) 800-0706 for a free consultation.
Reviewed by Joshua B. Adelpour, Esq., California State Bar No. 318226. Last updated November 4, 2026.